Regulations for the siting and design of rural houses in Co Clare “is going to impose a communist type house for everybody,” Cllr PJ Kelly has claimed.

For the last two successive meetings of Clare County Council, the veteran councillor has put forward the same question asking what determines “the appropriate siting of rural houses”, “the appropriate design of houses” and to reference the contents of the County Development Plan in support of that “which are in line with High Court decision on content and language of County Development Plan.”

Speaking at the January meeting of the local authority, Cllr Kelly admitted he raised the issue “with a sense of regret”. He referred to the years of 2003 and 2004 “where we had two different versions of the county development plan”. Kelly continued, “Tourism is mentioned in this chamber several times and our fore bearers built housing without planning and we got fairly good results”.

In his view, local powers were not to be blamed as they were receiving instructions “from high”, “We’re one step away from saying to people in rural places that they can only build houses in caves in future so that they can’t be seen from the roads”, “We’re doing everything possible to shut down rural Ireland. I think we have to stop hiding behind words, appropriate, inappropriate and define clearly”.

He was advised by Director of Service, Liam Conneally to see the rural housing guidelines to see “what’s considered appropriate and what’s not”. Senior Planner, Brian McCarthy confirmed 280 rural houses “were granted by Clare County Council” in 2018.

As he returned to the February gathering of the local authority, the Fianna Fáil politician brought with him the same question “on necessity”. Regarding the County Development Plan, he commented, “The more I went through it the more contradictions I found, I sympathise with the planners on the front line”.

An official reply from Mr Conneally outlined that “the considerations which determine siting and design of housing are set out in the Clare County Development Plan 2017-2023”. He flagged that regard must also be had to “the guidelines and policies issued by the Minister and the Government”. “Members will be aware of the Clare Rural House Design Guide which again provides advice, guidance and examples of considerations required in the appropriate siting and design for rural houses. The considerations of design and siting formed part of the assessment and granting permission in accordance with the provisions of the Development Plan of over 280 rural houses by Clare County Council Planning Authority in 2018”.

“There have been a number of High Court decisions regarding content and language of Development Plans and it unclear from the Notice of Motion which specific High Court decision is referred to. However for the avoidance of doubt, I am satisfied that the content and language of the Clare County Development Plan 2017-2023 is in compliance with the requirements of the Planning and Development Act 2000, as amended, the relevant Ministerial Guidelines and the precedents set out by Court decisions,” the Director of Service concluded.

Cllr Kelly told the recent meeting, “As we look back at the architecture of the last 50 years, we can look at the houses of the day, they were an expression of the people of the time and what they could afford. Universal design in other words means all houses in Clare will have to look the same. On one hand we say we’re going to protect our heritage and on the other we’re going to impose a communist type house for everybody, this to me is totally unacceptable”.

“What’s appropriate to me may not be appropriate to somebody else, it has no relation to what is being applied today maybe the word misappropriate might be more relevant in modern language. I’m very proud in this country that we have freedom of speech, other countries don’t, part of that expression is in our culture, I never thought I’d see the day, this is a dictatorship, we live in North Munster not North Korea. The CEO should call people aside and tell people to be less adventurous with language and more adventurous with common sense,” the Lissycasey representative declared.

Other councillors were precluded from joining the debate as the item was listed as a question. Council CEO, Pat Dowling in response to Kelly said, “I take it you’re not happy with the reply and I take your advice on board”.

Advertisement

Related News

rineen ns 1
11 Clare schools removed from Hot School Meals scheme
green cross pharmacy killaloe
Two men arrested who drove into Garda car after series of burglaries in Killaloe & Roscrea
gerardine joe quinlivan 1
Springfield residents can sleep soundly as flooding nightmare ends
ambulance coast guard scariff 1
Bodyke hurler recovering after picking up head injury which forced abandonment of game vs Whitegate
Latest News
clonlara v crusheen 23-08-25 oisin o'brien breffni horner 1
'We left it behind us against The Bridge' - Crusheen reflect on latest championship crusade
green cross pharmacy killaloe
Two men arrested who drove into Garda car after series of burglaries in Killaloe & Roscrea
naomh eoin v liscannor 03-08-25 darren nagle 1
Liscannor extend life in intermediate ranks & send Ennistymon into relegation decider
gerardine joe quinlivan 1
Springfield residents can sleep soundly as flooding nightmare ends
st josephs miltown vs doonbeg 30-08-25 conor cleary darragh burns 1
Miltown down Doonbeg and march onto quarter-finals
Premium
kildysart v kilmihil 29-08-25 conall casey stan lineen 1
Kildysart produce extra time kick to seal senior status & leave Kilmihil in relegation final
feakle v newmarket-on-fergus 08-08-25 oisin donnellan 1
'Next man up' the focus in Feakle despite injury crisis
Shannon, Ireland, June
Shannon will not receive 15 extra Gardaí despite claims of Govt TDs
Springfield3
€5.2m Springfield flood relief scheme 'makes fear & devastation of flooding a thing of the past' in Clonlara
st josephs miltown v doonbeg 16-08-24 sean neylon eoghan killeen 1
Doonbeg & Miltown to battle it out for last remaining quarter-final spot

Advertisement

Subscribe for just €3 per month

If you’re here, you care about County Clare. So do we. Did you rely on us for Covid-19 updates, follow our election coverage, or visit The Clare Echo every week for breaking news and sport? The Clare Echo invests in local journalism and we want to safeguard its future in our county. By becoming a subscriber you are supporting what we do, will receive access to all our premium articles and a better experience, while helping us improve our offering to you. Subscribe to clareecho.ie and get the first six months for just €3 a month (less than 75c per week), and thereafter €8 per month. Cancel anytime, limited time offer. T&Cs Apply. www.clareecho.ie.