Farming columnist Joe Melody this week writes about the appetite to control farmers.

Sometimes it is in the speaking to others about our thoughts or ideas that one garners further clarity on whatever the burning issue is. The weekend just gone was one of those moments, a neighbour of mine and I were discussing the issues with getting labour in tandem with the extra regulations and attacks on agriculture by bureaucracy. He made a point that summarised an underlying reason for much of the stifling of agriculture by regulation and activism. “It is all about control, you need land to build on, create infrastructure, renewable energy. The farmer owns the land so he has the power”.

Ireland does not have huge mineral deposits or onshore oil reserves so intrinsically land is the only real wealth this nation has if you exclude foreign direct investment because that capital is fluid and flows to wherever the most attractive tax policy is or educated work force resides. When we start to frame the conversation about farmers as being a powerful constituency of people who own most the state’s wealth it is easy to see why many on mainly the left of the political spectrum would like to further regulate agriculture and indeed stifle its productivity. Much of this opprobrium levelled at agriculture doesn’t just come from an ill-informed place of concern, it comes from an underlying Marxist view of the world.

In this Marxist view of the world, those that own the means of production in most cases the land are labelled the Bourgeoisie. One only has to look at the horrors of the 20th century in Russia and the communist revolution to see what happened when the farmers were ran off their lands and a communist system was imposed. Of course we say that this could never happen today in a western country. Well maybe not to that extent but most things sit on a spectrum rather than a binary choice of capitalism versus Marxism. The further the hand of government reaches into our affairs as citizens never mind business or farm owners, the further we are ceding control of our land and property rights.

In a country like ours land ownership is an emotive issue and why wouldn’t it be after centuries of being under British rule. I feel though now that a history lesson is needed on why for example Russia with its rich deep black soils is still struggling as an agricultural nation after years of communism. Why also America flourished for centuries under a system of limited government and why the term was “the American dream”.

So next time you hear or read about extra unnecessary controls over the productive sectors, ask the question why. It usually stems from a place of control rather than a place of concern. Productive people do not impose unproductive controls on others. However a small group of people with Marxist tendencies are generating the noise and narrative that these farmers need to be regulated. They will continue to berate any area of society that owns the means of production whether it be land or some SME providing local employment.

Related News

image00001edit
ASafe Global grow international operation from Ennis Headquarters
doolin pier swimming 1
Fresh calls to fight for Doolin's designation as bathing area
Trump Resort Doonbeg
Council to hold meeting at Trump Doonbeg 'to prove 100% support of resort & its coastal protection plans'
ballycar flooding rail march 2024
'A let-down to rural Ireland' - Clare councillors slam inaction on solving Ballycar flooding
Latest News
Homestead Cottage braised-lamb-shoulder-768x960 (1)
A taste of Homestead Cottage's Alternative Easter Lamb
firearm-409252_1280
Judge grants domestic violence order to woman after ex-partner brandished loaded shot-gun in row
image00001edit
ASafe Global grow international operation from Ennis Headquarters
doolin pier swimming 1
Fresh calls to fight for Doolin's designation as bathing area
Trump Resort Doonbeg
Council to hold meeting at Trump Doonbeg 'to prove 100% support of resort & its coastal protection plans'
Premium
paul bugler tony killeen darragh mcallister páraic mcmahon 1-2
The Electoral Chair - Varadkar's Earthquake / Clare's political climate / Standout councillors & those stepping away
clare v antrim 16-03-24 mark fitzgerald 1
Clare must cut down on basic errors or face being 'torn alive' by Down - Fitzgerald
tralee court 1
Meelick man with 82 previous convictions sent to prison
máire ní mhurchú 1-2
Short-term lets 'a nice but significant generator of income for rural Clare communities'
analog devices leo varadkar 6
Varadkar resignation won't cause earlier General Election says Clare TD & Senator

Subscribe for just €3 per month

If you’re here, you care about County Clare. So do we. Did you rely on us for Covid-19 updates, follow our election coverage, or visit The Clare Echo every week for breaking news and sport? The Clare Echo invests in local journalism and we want to safeguard its future in our county. By becoming a subscriber you are supporting what we do, will receive access to all our premium articles and a better experience, while helping us improve our offering to you. Subscribe to clareecho.ie and get the first six months for just €3 a month (less than 75c per week), and thereafter €8 per month. Cancel anytime, limited time offer. T&Cs Apply. www.clareecho.ie.

Subscribe for just €3 per month

If you’re here, you care about County Clare. So do we. Did you rely on us for Covid-19 updates, follow our election coverage, or visit The Clare Echo every week for breaking news and sport? The Clare Echo invests in local journalism and we want to safeguard its future in our county. By becoming a subscriber you are supporting what we do, will receive access to all our premium articles and a better experience, while helping us improve our offering to you. Subscribe to clareecho.ie and get the first six months for just €3 a month (less than 75c per week), and thereafter €8 per month. Cancel anytime, limited time offer. T&Cs Apply. www.clareecho.ie.

Scroll to Top