*The Fiddle Head Bar. Photograph: Patrick Clohessy.
A judge has granted a renewal licence application for a West Clare pub despite an objection by a Miltown Malbay man against the renewal.
At Kilrush District Court, Judge Adrian Harris granted the licence renewal to Gerard Mahon and Susan Mahon for their pub in the west Clare village of Kilmihil.
In granting the renewal to the Mahons, Judge Harris praised the ‘very reasonable’ approach taken by objector, Declan Murray of Church View, Main Street, Miltown Malaby after hearing the background to the objection put forward by his solicitor, Natalie O’Shea.
In court, Ms O’Shea said that her client was objecting to the licence renewal after Mr Mahon’s failure to engage with Mr Murray on his personal injuries action against the pub.
Ms O’Shea said that Mr Murray had previously been engaged by Mr Mahon for maintenance works at his bar in Kilmihil.
She said: “He fell off a ladder during the course of those works and fractured both of his ankles and a personal injury action arose.”
Ms O’Shea said: “Throughout the case, there was no engagement whatsoever from Mr Mahon and it took to bring this application for there to be any engagement.”
She explained that the personal injury action was before the High Court sitting in Ennis last June and Mr Justice Nolan was not impressed that Mr Mahon had not engaged.
Ms O’Shea said: “It does now transpire from correspondence received from solicitor for the Mahons, Joe Chambers that Mr Mahon did have an insurance policy in place at the time of the accident but failed to notify his insurance company in time.”
She said that Mr Murray “doesn’t want to see Mr Mahon out of business and understands that everyone has to make a livelihood and he is anxious that what has happened here would not occur to anyone else”.
Ms O’Shea said that Mr Murray is eager that there is some engagement from Mr Mahon and if an assurance can be given to the court that an insurance policy is now in place and also engagement on the substantive matter, he would be satisfied.
On behalf of the Mahons, solicitor Joe Chambers said that Ms O’Shea had very fairly put forward the circumstances.
Mr Chambers said that the licence in is both names of husband and wife and through Mr Mahon’s neglect, he believed that nothing was going to happen with this case and only when a summons was served that his wife became aware of it and she reported the matter to the insurers.
Mr Chambers said that Mr Mahon made a statement to the insurance firm and the insurance firm took the view that it was a late notification and they refused to provide cover.
Mr Chambers said that there would be engagement from Mr Mahon on the substantive matter.
Judge Harris noted that Mr Murray did not wish for the licence holder to be deprived of a livelihood but wanted engagement on the personal injury action matter.
Judge Harris said that it is open to Mr Murray to object again next year if there is no engagement.
He said: “It is an issue that it is not going to go away. The position taken by the objector is very reasonable in the circumstances.”