*Councillor Mary Howard at the BreastCheck clinic in Ennis. Photograph: Arthur Ellis
WOMEN in Clare should not be disadvantaged when accessing breast screening because of where they live, councillors have said, as they called for improved local provision and consideration of a permanent BreastCheck facility in Ennis.
A joint motion from Cllrs Antoinette Baker Bashua (FF), David Griffin (FF), Rita McInerney (FF), Clare Colleran Molloy (FF), Mary Howard (FG) and Rachel Hartigan (FF) called on the Minister for Health, the HSE and BreastCheck to provide an explanation for the relocation of the mobile unit from Ennis to County Mayo on October 30.
The councillors also sought clarification on whether the move was temporary or longer-term, a confirmed date for the unit’s return to Ennis, and details of how many Clare women were still awaiting screening.
They called for assurances that the relocation would not lead to delays or reduced access to screening, alongside a review of the frequency of BreastCheck services in Clare and consideration of a permanent facility in Ennis.
Speaking on the motion, Cllr Antoinette Baker Bashua (FF) said that while women in Mayo also deserved access to screening, the impact of the relocation on women in Clare needed to be examined.
She highlighted the additional difficulties faced by women in areas such as Kilkee, Doonbeg, Miltown Malbay, Kilrush and rural North Clare, particularly those who did not drive, had caring responsibilities or needed to take time off work to attend an appointment elsewhere.
She said approximately 17,000 women in Clare had been invited for screening during the most recent programme, with a 71% uptake.
While the reasons why some women did not attend were not known, she said accessibility was an issue that needed to be examined.
“A screening service is only truly accessible when people can realistically get to it,” she said.
Cllr Baker Bashua acknowledged that keeping a mobile unit permanently in Ennis would require significant demand, staffing and resources, but said Clare deserved a proper assessment of whether more frequent and guaranteed local screening could improve access and attendance.
She welcomed confirmation that the mobile unit was expected to return to Ennis in September 2027, but said the longer-term provision of screening services across Clare also needed to be examined.
She said the issue was not about Clare competing with Mayo or any other county, but about ensuring women were not disadvantaged because of where they lived.
Cllr David Griffin (FF) said the issue was not just a concern for women and criticised how the relocation had been communicated.
He said communication had been “so poorly handled”, adding that service providers needed to get ahead of stories and provide clear information before an information vacuum developed.
Cllr Rita McInerney (FF) also called for greater consideration of how the service could be delivered across the county, suggesting that the mobile unit could visit different locations in Clare to improve access if a permanent facility could not be secured.
She said the unit’s expected return to Ennis in 2027 was a testament to the need for the service, but asked whether the frequency of visits could be increased.
Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy (FF) said she had received numerous calls from concerned people following the announcement, adding that steps had been taken to move the unit without proper communication.
Cllr Mary Howard (FG) said the issue was a hugely emotional one and warned against a narrative that Clare was losing the service.
She encouraged women to attend their appointments, including at screening centres in Limerick and Galway while the unit is not in Ennis, and stressed that early detection was key.
Cllr Rachel Hartigan (FF) welcomed the motion and said the poor communication had allowed gaps to develop, causing distress among women affected by the changes.
She also supported the idea of the mobile unit travelling to different parts of the county.
Cllr Pat Daly (FF) described the relocation as “not good enough” and said Clare had been “let down again”.
Cllr Tom O’Callaghan (FF) said there was concern about the number of women not taking up screening invitations, while Cllr Joe Garrihy (FG) said communication from the HSE had “left an awful lot to be desired”.
Cllr Ian Lynch (IND) described the communication as “atrocious” and said the HSE Mid West Regional Health Forum should be used to ensure councillors receive advance notice of significant changes to services in the county.
In her closing remarks, Cllr Baker Bashua said BreastCheck was about giving women the best possible chance of early diagnosis and timely treatment.
“BreastCheck is not just about screening. It is about giving women the best possible chance of early diagnosis, timely treatment and a future with the people they love, because at the end of the day, the distance a woman has to travel should not – it should never – be the reason she delays screening,” she said.
Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme